Donate   |   Search   |   Contact Us   |   Sign In
Community Search
Intellectual Property Content
Share |

 

Intellectual Property Content

 

 

MAY 2017

Lost Profit Calculations in Patent Cases Clarified In Recent Federal Circuit Decision

 

In March 2017, The Federal Circuit issued its decision in Mentor Graphics Corp. v. EVE-USA, Inc. 851 F.3d 1275 (Fed. Cir. 2017). This decision provides some needed guidance on how lost profits are calculated in patent cases, an area where there had been conflicting decisions in the district courts. The underlying dispute concerns a patent for a feature of an emulator, a machine that tests for bugs in computer chips.


This was a complex case with a long history. In the district court, the jury found that the defendant had infringed on two features of the plaintiff’s patent and awarded the plaintiff $36 million. On appeal, the defendant argued that the $36 million damage award was improper as it should have reflected an apportionment analysis that factored in non-infringing features for product sales. In other words, defendant argued that plaintiff was not entitled to the lost sales, but only the value attributable to plaintiff’s features of the emulator. The Federal Circuit disagreed and held that once the four Panduit test factors are met,[1] apportionment is taken into consideration as lost profits are tied to “specific claim limitations and ensure that damages are commensurate with the value of the patented features.” 851 F.3d at 1288. Thus it upheld the jury damages award. 

 

The defendant has sought a rehearing before the full panel. Stay tuned.



[1] A patentee is entitled to lost profits if it can establish (1) a demand for the patented product; (2) absence of acceptable non-infringing alternatives; (3) manufacturing and marketing capability to exploit the demand; and (4) the amount of profit it would have made. Panduit Corp. v. Stahlin Bros. Fibre Works, 575 F.2d 1152, 1156 (6th Cir. 1978)

 

more Calendar

6/4/2017 » 6/8/2017
23rd Annual Litigation Management College

6/4/2017 » 6/8/2017
14th Annual LMC Graduate Program

6/12/2017 » 6/13/2017
Deposition Boot Camp

7/24/2017 » 7/29/2017
2017 FDCC Annual Meeting/ Bridging The Gap Insurance Summit

9/17/2017 » 9/19/2017
Corporate Counsel Symposium

Featured Members
Marjorie J. BergerMarjorie is with American Nuclear Insurers in CT
Bradford D. BoxBrad Box is with Rainey, Kizer, Reviere & Bell in TN

Special Thanks

Membership Software Powered by YourMembership  ::  Legal